Everything I Hate Is Corrupt
Let’s Fisk again, like we did last summer. (Actually, winter).
Making the Impossible Possible – 5,000 Signatures in Two Weeks
You’ve likely been following the recent developments. The party has predetermined their choice for Congressman Higgins’ successor, bypassing the democratic process. This isn’t a secret conspiracy; it’s all happening openly. To challenge them, I will need to get 5,000 notarized signature in two weeks, in freezing cold February—ouch.
We could have a conversation in good faith about whether ECDC should endorse in a primary at all, but to whine that you didn’t get the nod, after you had spent over a year bad-mouthing and spewing hatred at the committee is a bit much.
They’ve labeled me as a problematic outsider for even considering challenging their crony system, but I see it as standing up for true Democratic values. I hope you do too. If you don’t, I’m guessing you benefit from the crony system with some job or appointment? If not, how can you justify so many politicians in office for decades with so much poverty and grief?
There’s no “crony system” when the county committee holds a process whereby its executive committee interviews multiple candidates and selects the best-qualified one who is loyal to the apparatus and has experience raising money and winning campaigns. There’s no “crony system” when the committee then holds a vote to back a particular candidate over one who does nothing but bad-mouth the committee over and over again. Tim Kennedy has been a State Senator – a legislator – for about 15 years. Nate McMurray has been a Tweeter and professional perennial campaigner. The result should not come as a surprise.
When I say crony system, I mean it. Your average person doesn’t realize how many lawyers, consultants, even bloggers live off the local Democratic machine. I might be fine with that if the machine was successful in helping the people of WNY. But the leadership’s reluctance to oppose even MAGA Republicans—they nominate them!— and their aversion to progressive policies reveals their priorities.
I’d like Nate to please name the “progressive policy” that the Erie County Democratic Committee is “averse” to, and I’d like a full roster of the “MAGA Republicans” whom the committee has nominated. Because the answers, respectively, are “very few” and “none”. Judicial nominations don’t count.
Consider this: the former chief of staff of Congressman Higgins (who just resigned), with no apparent water management expertise, lands a lucrative job at the water authority by appointment. What does he know about water? Especially when our water system is so plagued by failures, with lead in the pipes, and no fluoride for months. Is this how a party truly committed to Democratic principles should operate?
Chuck Eaton, whom Nate is referencing here, has forgotten more about politics than Nate could ever know. He knows more about getting people and entities with competing interests to cooperate, and pulling together consensus than Nate could ever imagine. Chuck has an innate (un-Nate?) ability to listen and persuade people – both Republicans and Democrats – to advance policies that help WNY. To hire someone with deep and longstanding knowledge and experience in dealing with federal and state government to help run a water authority is a brilliant move, if ever that authority wants to get state or federal assistance or funding.
What does Chuck Eaton know about water? As much as he needs to. What he knows about is how governments function, and how they function together, and how they function within the context of public authorities. He knows the people and he knows the institutions. Also, it was only City of Buffalo water that has not been flouridated – not Erie County Water. They are two separate and distinct systems. You would think that someone wanting to run for Congress to represent Buffalo would be aware of this detail and not try – falsely – to weaponize it to make a dumb point or to demonize someone who has only ever helped him. If he wants to remove and replace lead pipes, great! Maybe ensure that the ECWA is eligible for federal grants to do it.
My refusal to conform to this system—to take a cut and stay quiet—has drawn ire from both Republicans and Democrats who fear change. But change is precisely what I promise. No more cronyism, no more kickbacks, no more lifelong politicians. In Washington, I’ll advocate for term limits – it’s time for leaders who make an impact and then step aside.
The reason why you “draw ire” from Democrats, Nate, is because you are a backstabbing malcontent. You squandered innumerable support and money – you treated people with such contempt exactly the moment they became of little use to you; you are everything you purport to hate about politics. While the people in ECDC were busy in 2023 getting Democrats elected, where were you? You were making a fool of yourself in court and pontificating on Twitter about your various grievances. Meanwhile, Tim Kennedy was doing his job, and sending almost $300,000 to the state Democratic Committee.
They try to discredit me—and anyone else who resists—even comparing me to the worst offenders, including Trump himself. But their accusations are fluff if you even crack into them. I am clean. No underhanded political donations. No dirty money. No plush appointments for my buddies. I am an outsider by choice. It is not me who has to be ashamed. It’s them.
You’re an unrestrained narcissist clumsily airing your myriad grievances and marshalling an ever-shrinking cult of personality. The comparison is apt. You’re an outsider by default – because you stabbed everyone in the back, out of spite. And us? We are ashamed. Ashamed ever to have supported you or to give you money. Or time.
I’m doing this solo
No shit.
– no lobbyists, no big money. Just me, my truck, and a belief in the untapped potential of Western New York. I’m not here to perpetuate backroom politics but to benefit all our communities. And that’s why I remain popular, despite millions spent to shut me out.
Yes, the untapped potential of WNY to what – to deliver you a Nike store and an Ikea.
My message—democracy, independence, free thought—is probably your message. It resonates across the political spectrum. I’m just grateful I help share it. Despite the odds and the opposition, this a joy for me. A blessing and an opportunity.
Your message is arrogance, hatred, jealousy, and grievance.
As a kid, my mom had this quote crocheted and hanging on the wall: “In a room where people unanimously maintain a conspiracy of silence, one word of truth sounds like a pistol shot.” — Czesław Miłosz
The sheer arrogance! A blonde, blue-eyed corporate lawyer from the suburbs with an Irish surname equating his naked ambition with the plight of artists in exile struggling against the malign forces of totalitarianism is so lacking in self-awareness that it has to be a joke. Milosz did not deliver that speech in a vacuum, but as a particular person from a particular place at a particular time in history – 1980, mere months after Solidarity openly began challenging the Communist Party’s political, social, and economic hegemony over the Polish state.
Nate McMurray is no Lech Walesa.
That’s why I still get the attention I do. I speak the truth, and many of you speak that same truth with me: The status quo has failed WNY, and we believe in Buffalo and Niagara region that is based on fairness, hope, and progress.
It’s all about Nate. And the people who follow Nate.
So, how can you help echo this truth? Oppose entrenched corruption. Push for change. Push for fairness. Help me get on the ballot. It’s not about donations; it’s about your signature. They think it’s impossible to do in two weeks in February. They think they can steamroll not only you but all of us. Let’s prove them wrong.
I wish someone would employ this person so he would finally free us from his various narcissistic manic episodes.
One highly-placed Democratic Party insider told me that “McMurray is a fabulist – a ginger George Santos.”
Except Santos was actually elected to Congress on his first try.
I never met Nate but through the constant rigamarole he has stirred since deciding to be a perennial candidate I wonder if he is not some sort of renegade MAGA refugee who hoped his Irish name would get traction in Erie County Democrats.
He certainly snatches easy defeat in areas he might have thrived like Grand Island.
Reading through his letter I get the impression of a perpetual but resentful outsider. Nate is like the MAGA’s who just never grasped politics is a structure of governance that is necessarily hierarchical that must satisfy a lot of various interest groups.