I’m Offended You’re Offended

It’s a jokey thing to do – “pardon the butter lamb”. Erie County Executive Poloncarz did that sometime during that week before Easter when Polish WNYers rediscover their old neighborhood.  This attempt at humor (you can’t really pardon a thing that doesn’t live) has outraged at least one person,

In what at first appeared to be a harmless political stunt, Erie County Executive Mark C. Poloncarz ventured over to the Broadway Market to pardon a butter lamb today. For some community leaders in touch with their Christian faiths, it wasn’t so harmless after all.

“It is clear that Mr. Poloncarz and his staff are blatantly ignorant to the significance of the butter lamb and its portrayal of Jesus as the Lamb of God. The title Lamb of God was given to Jesus by the Apostle John to clarify to the flock that in giving his life for mankind, he embodied the ultimate sacrifice,” said one Catholic political insider. “For Mark Poloncarz to think he has the ability and authority to pardon that sacrifice, eliminating it’s necessity – even if it was just a political stunt – is incredibly offensive. We are in the midst of the holiest week in the liturgical calendar, and there is just no room for such ignorance.”

The first reaction a reasonable person might have might be, “lighten up, Francis”.

The second reaction might be to pose a question. If the lump of butter molded into a lamb shape and sold in a box is such a holy portrayal of Jesus, why are we cutting it with a knife and eating it? Are we all Romans, symbolically sacrificing a dairy portrayal of the Messiah?

It was a joke – a marketing stunt.  It was an effort to promote Buffalo, the Broadway Market, our Easter traditions, Polish heritage, and the company that makes the butter lamb. Google it, and you’ll notice that the stunt worked – it was picked up as a “weird news” story on the AP wire, and  ABC, MSN, Fox, the Times of Malta,  and the Washington Post all ran the story.  Poloncarz didn’t just pardon any old lamb, but one manufactured by the Malczewski company, which gleefully promoted the Poloncarz pardon on its Facebook page.

How does the “Catholic insider” jibe his offense with Exodus 20:4 – 6?

Maybe don’t be so offended. He wasn’t really pardoning anything, and the butter lamb isn’t Jesus. 


  • “Catholic insider” lol, so the quote is either made up or the person in question is a complete coward.

  • I wonder how many of these offended Catholics and Christians ate shellfish over lent and wear blended fabrics, both of which are such an affront to God that He forbade them in the bible. *rolls eyes*

  • Ridgewaycynic2013

    As Mrs. Ridgewaycynic2013 puts it, “I’m sure even Jesus had a sense of humour”. Perhaps the ‘Catholic political insider’ shouldn’t take him/herself so seriously.

  • I am always entertained when bible banging people start getting into religious minutiae. Reminds me of the guy who invented the “Klingon” language.

  • So, pardoning one is bad while butchering one and smearing its entrails onto a Kings Hawaiian is ok?

  • Maybe next year he should crucify the fucker

  • Ha; I was an oh, so lucky recipient of the same email. After getting outraged for a moment, I shook my head, realized the sources and deleted it. I wish I had kept it and written something this good.

    • OK, I goofed; I read it at a website. The political email rumors/stupidity I’ve been receiving lately have ramped up a bit.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.