The Dog-Whistle Election of 2012

It was reported yesterday that an un-named advisor to Mitt Romney complained to a foreign publication how President Obama doesn’t share or “appreciate” the shared “Anglo-Saxon heritage” of America and Great Britain. The Romney campaign itself later disavowed this unbelievably stupid comment, but that’s not dissimilar to a celebrity apologizing for an insensitive Tweet. 

You know they meant every word of it. They just realized that it was inconvenient. 

First of all, Anglo-Saxon Britain ended in 1066 with the Norman conquest at Hastings. Like their persistent use of “Soviet” and “Soviet Union” to describe the country known as the “Russian Federation”, the Romney folks need to brush up on their history. 

Secondly, this is all part of a wider theme that’s taken hold of much of the American right since Obama’s nomination and election. It all has to do with painting Obama as a foreign savage devil. How that characterization is made depends somewhat on the person making it, and the intended audience. It may also have something to do with the intelligence of the person making the characterization. 

For instance, the extremely dumb and ignorant – oft racist – will simply aver that the President is a foreign-born Kenyan who was raised at a madrassa in Indonesia as part of a worldwide Communist/Muslim conspiracy to take over the United States – a plot dating back to 1961 at least. People mildly more intelligent will simply “ask questions” about the President’s birthplace and loyalty. 

The less stupid will say they don’t doubt the President’s birth certificate is real, and “take him at his word” that he’s Christian. The scale slides as people more benignly accuse Obama of “not sharing our values”, or being “socialist”, or going around the world “apologizing for America”. 

All of it has a central theme of Republican omniphobia, and of being so fundamentally out of ideas – ideas that plunged the world into a couple of quagmire-y wars and a crushing, long-lasting worldwide economic crisis – that this is all they have to fall back on. Literal demonization of the foreign usurper President, and urging reversion to the very policies that got us into this mess in the first place. 

Obama may not be perfect, but he’s not a foreign Communist savage, either. Mitt Romney, however, is by no means the answer to any sane or rational question. 


  • Quibble: Anglo-Saxon England continued for a long time after the conquest and shapes England and English to this day, despite perfidious Norman Rule. And if blood means anything (and of course, it doesn’t), Barack H. Obama is fully one-half Anglo-Saxon, on his mother’s side, unless Romney’s advisers are knuckle-dragging “one drop of blood rule” racists (and of course, they are). 

    • I had the same thought about that 1/2 of Obama’s genes no one ever mentions.  I wonder if the right would have the same views of him if his father had been white and his mother Kenyan. 

  • While the plot hatched by the savage devil had its origins in 1961, let’s not forget the year 1861, which is a world that many of BHO’s detractors inhabit.

  • What is even sadder is that Romney can win this election, despite the fact that he will not articulate a single policy or proposed  plan at any point.  He can merely point to his white face and guarantee himself at least 35% of the popular vote.  

    • Romney’s platform is ” I am not the socialist, anti business, big government, job killing black guy with a foreign sounding name”

  • I am surprised how many otherwise seemingly reasonable people still question Obama’s birthplace. I have relatives and acquaintances that appear intelligent and are not far right nutjobs yet they cling to this ridiculous idea. When I point out the birth notice in the newspaper they offer no explanation but just ignore this conclusive evidence. The right has does an excellent job of planting the seeds of doubt, they have succeeded in not just convincing the base that Obama is not legitimate but also a large part of the middle.

    • The Obama birth is the Kennedy Assasination is the Founding Fathers as esoteric Masons. Perfectly reasonable people think there were multiple shooters and that George Washington led a cult – there will be exhaustive books and inqueries on this for years to come.

  • It’s not really an election anyway.

    Real ballots have been replaced by blackboxes. They’re exorbitantly expensive, unreliable, unsecured, and known to lose, switch, and fake votes. Nobody has any right to vote when forced to turn it over to an unknown and unknowable proprietary proxy. Americans need to gain ownership of their elections. 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.